Another Moderation Request / Appeal

Posts: 2 · Views: 51
  • 21979

    Maybe a mod will respond to this one.

    [md529m] [j5pv3y] [83vd9o] All reported as low quality I'm guessing for "noise". The first two are from the original Star Trek, shot on film, in the 60's! Yeah there's going to be film grain. As for the last one, it's a dusk scene and IMHO the "noise" doesn't detract for the overall quality of the image.

  • 21980

    We allow some things to pass when it comes to older media, but the uploads in question you posted had issues we could not overlook. For the first two, you posted one at 3440 x 1440 resolution (not sure why the original 60's film would use that resolution if it's a video rip). I'm fairly certain this is an upscale due to lots of digital noise that is common with higher resolution upscales.

    For the last one, that is a rip from the Mandalorian IIRC. If you can find a "high quality" rip without any of the noise issues from that modern show then you may upload it. I suggest you view it at full resolution before doing so though.

Message